I love books, but I am not a particular lover of paper. For years now, most of my "reading" (where fiction is concerned, at least) has been done via audiobooks. I am also receptive to ebooks, and feel that certain books actually offer much more functionality in electronic form than in hard copy: travel guides, tech books, pretty much anything where the ability to easily jump to a specific topic of interest is desirable. With the advent of the Vook and book apps for the iPad and iPhone, I've looked forward to seeing what an "enhanced" novel might have to offer. The answer to that question---at the present time, at least---is disappointment.
For my first foray into the world of book apps, I decided to go with an award-winning, best-of-breed title: Dracula: The Official Stoker Family Edition, produced by Padworx Digital Media, Inc. I'd read many glowing reviews of this book app online, and since I've also read the book in the old-fashioned, paper-pulp format, it was an ideal candidate for comparison and evaluation.
First off, let me say the book app is beautiful to look at and the music is both lovely and entirely suitable for the subject matter. There are interactive elements on many pages. In one instance, you must move a virtual lantern around over a darkened page to read it. In another, you can bring a background illustration into better and brighter focus by touching it. In yet another, you must move a crucifix necklace about where it hangs over the page in order to see the text beneath it. Sounds cool, right? Well, these interactive features ARE cool, but they also pulled me right out of the story.
The experience of reading the book very quickly devolved into an exercise of hunting for "easter eggs", the term used for hidden bonus features in computer programs, on DVDs and Blu-Ray discs. You can't always tell by looking at a given page of the app whether or not it contains interactive elements, so I found myself reading the text and then tapping all around on the screen to check for those elements. On the pages that don't have them, all the tapping is for naught.
The experience ends up falling somewhere between playing a video game and reading an ebook, but it's not a very good experience of either one. If the app were a full-fledged video game, I'd want interactivity on every page and I'd want it to be more extensive in terms of controlling my experience of the content. When I play a video game, I want my choices and actions to have consequences beyond causing formerly hidden images to display and being able to move objects around on a screen. Conversely, in an ebook, I want to feel immersed in the story world, to lose my awareness of the device on which the ebook is displayed; if you must tap or click all around on each screen to expose and enjoy the interactive elements, this is impossible.
I thought this might be a case of this specific book app not being my cup of tea, so I also decided to check out another much-lauded title, the War of the Worlds book app from Smashing Ideas, Inc. Again, as a literary classic I'd read previously, it seemed a terrific pick. And again, I was disappointed.
With the WotW app, the interactive illustrations are not as numerous as in the Dracula app, though they are just as beautiful. However, I still had to tap around on them to find the hidden goodies, which was kind of annoying and again, took me right out of the story.
I've pondered how this issue might be overcome, and I'm stumped. Even if some sort of indication were given as to the location of the interactive elements (as is the case for some of the Dracula app content), the moment you're tapping the screen and thinking, "Cool!" at whatever happens, you're no longer gripped in the terror of Castle Dracula or an alien invasion, you're admiring the technology.
The good news is, I think the book app is still very much in its infancy and publishers and developers just don't know quite what to do with the capabilities of the technology yet. My prediction is that where novels are concerned, the book app will find its full flower in a sort of purposeful hybrid of book and video game. And yes, the words will no longer be the stars of the show in most cases, much as it is with movies. Every year there are those few, standout examples of films that are worth seeing for the sake of the whip-smart and insightful script alone. The Social Network is an example of that type of film. But most often, moviegoers are satisfied to be thrilled by action, wowed by special effects, or cracked up by comedy.
Such entertainments are largely disposable, and while it pains me to say so, I'm afraid this may prove to be the future of literature. Every year there will be a handful of new books that are worth actually reading, simply as words on the page, and for these the experience will be one of good, old-fashioned theater of the mind. But for the rest, consumers will come to expect the play to be delivered not only pre-scripted, but with the cast, costumes, sets, stunts and special effects already in place, with the reader empowered to act as director of the entire production via its interactive elements.
But this raises another, and I think thornier issue: in the case of a completely original interactive book app (as opposed to the re-imaginings of literary classics examined here), assuming a team of people were involved in creation and production of the app, who is actually the Author? I'm not sure that title will be apt for anyone involved in such a project, since the consumer's eventual experience of the content will not be limited to the written words, but driven just as substantially by the multimedia and interactivity of the app. I suspect it's more likely that the person we used to think of as the author will be given a "Written By" and/or "Story By" name check in the credits of the app.
If I'm right about that, it's a double-edged sword. On the one hand, there should be more and better opportunities for writers to see their works produced and brought to an audience; maybe aspiring authors should start querying book app companies like Smashing Ideas and Padworx right alongside agents and publishers. But on the other hand, those writers won't get quite the same level of recognition and prestige as in the past. Is this a good thing, or a bad thing? As of yet, I'm uncertain.
Monday, January 24, 2011
Interactive Novels: Not So Much
Posted by April L. Hamilton at 10:31 AM
Labels: book apps, ebooks, interactive books, publishing technology
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
Why do they want to be so mean to their customers? Wow. What value is that adding besides "Look what we can do?"
I disagree with you about the movie experience. The mainstream movie business is dying precisely because they go for shallow, non-risky, big-scale entertainment. For most Americans, there's a choice of maybe a half dozen movies at any one time. It's no wonder the indie world has exploded because of all the suppressed hunger for good content of rich variety.
I do think book apps will evolve into a coherent medium but it's yet to be invented.
The problem is that the interactive elements are done 'just because we can' instead of because they add to the experience. The also pick books which with a lot of drama, so it's easy to create video/music.
I think interactivity is more appropriate for non-fiction than fiction. If I want to see a movie, I don't grab an eDevice.
Ah, the shock and awe of technology.
Alas, the insipid minds of those who cater to the current mind-set of our materialistic culture.
Will we one day have an underground of book readers, skulking about, trying to find a ray of light from the window of a multimedia company?
I think I'd rather check out of life before that could happen...
I agree with steelweed, interactivity is a wonderful idea for nonfiction, particularly educational/training nonfiction. I've always looked on the vook and now enhanced books as gimmick. I think it is wonderful that people are exploring the realm of the possible with these new technologies, but it will take quite a while to separate the good ideas from the gimmicks.
What happened to bookconnect.com that you mentioned in the author guide? And are you doing the rotational pics thing or no? From what I can tell, it doesn't seem you're active; hope I'm wrong!
Not sure what you mean. The site I think you're talking about is bookconnector.com, and while it's a site I recommend, I don't have anything to do with its operations.
Regarding the rotating book covers, to date I've only received one response so I haven't set up the slideshow yet. Get those cover images and links in, people! =')
Otherwise, I'm just very, very busy with running Publetariat, working on Kindlenationdaily.com, freelance work and being a mom. Been meaning to post for a while, but nothing's gotten my hackles up enough to seem urgent lately, and blogging is (unfortunately) not very high on my lengthy priority list right now. ='/
I have a "nephew" of sorts who is graduating from RIT. I want him to create the book applications that can do the following: spray a perfume, show action clips, allow the reader to choose different story lines and outcomes, allow readers to write comments and effects not like gaming but where they have to spell check...
Perhaps in our time ebooks will offer full on reality without having to live?
Post a Comment